Home › Homes for Sale › New Haven, CT › 538 Chapel Street

538 Chapel Street, New Haven, CT 06511

Multi-Family For Sale · 4 Family

$1,190,000
$284/sqft

Photos not available yet

Check back soon or contact us for more details

6
Bedrooms
4
Bathrooms
4,194
Sq Ft
0.14
Acres
1844
Year Built

About This Home

Historic Wooster Square FourFamily - Steps to the Park. Beautifully positioned just steps from Wooster Square Park, this circa1835 fourfamily blends historic architecture with modern updates and excellent upside for both owneroccupants and investors. Current rents are below market, offering significant potential for increased income. The property includes two tandem offstreet parking spaces, separate utilities (shared ondemand hot water heater), common laundry, and a deep backyard with both a storage shed and potting shed. The front three units feature great natural light, hardwood floors, vintage details, and strong crossventilation. The renovated rear twolevel apartment offers minisplits, radiantheated floors, a private deck, and bonus finished basement rooms with a full bath. Many mechanicals have been updated, including newer furnaces, minisplits, and a newer hot water system. A prior layout combined the two firstfloor units into one large apartment, providing excellent flexibility for an owneroccupant seeking expanded space. A rare opportunity in one of New Haven's most desirable neighborhoods, moments from Yale, downtown, and the city's best restaurants.

Listed by Cheryl Szczarba (203) 996-8328 with Seabury Hill REALTORS (203) 562-1220

Listing Snapshot

Price $1,190,000 Days on Market —
Property Tax $21,736/yr Style Units on different Floors
Year Built 1844 Total Sq Ft 4,194
Lot Size 0.14 acres HOA Fees N/A
Bedrooms 6 Full Bathrooms 4
Total Rooms 14 Half Baths 0

Key Features

Nearby
  • Bocci Court
  • Park
  • Playground/Tot Lot
  • Public Transportation

Structure & Parking

Construction Frame
Roof Asphalt Shingle
Garage Type Driveway

Systems & Utilities

Heat Baseboard, Hot Air, Radiant, Radiator
Fuel Electric, Natural Gas
Cooling Central Air, Ductless
Hot Water Natural Gas, Tankless Hotwater
Water Public Water Connected
Sewer Public Sewer Connected

Schools

Elem Conte-West
High James Hillhouse

Mortgage Calculator

$
$
%
%
Est. Monthly Payment —
Principal & Interest —
Est. Property Tax $1,811/mo
Est. Home Insurance —

Estimate only. Contact a lender for accurate figures.

Listing History

Date Event Price
Apr 17, 2026 Listed $1,190,000

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does 538 Chapel Street in New Haven, CT cost?
This property is listed at $1,190,000, which works out to $284 per square foot.
How many bedrooms does 538 Chapel Street have?
This home has 6 bedrooms and 4 bathrooms.
What is the square footage of 538 Chapel Street?
The home is 4,194 square feet, situated on 0.14 acres.
When was 538 Chapel Street in New Haven built?
This property was built in 1844.
Is 538 Chapel Street, New Haven, CT still available?
The current MLS status of this property is "Coming Soon". Contact RYZE Realty Group for the latest availability.
What school district is 538 Chapel Street, New Haven in?
This home is served by the New Haven public school system, with Conte-West as the elementary school and James Hillhouse as the high school.
How do I schedule a tour of 538 Chapel Street, New Haven, CT?
Contact RYZE Realty Group to schedule a private showing. You can submit a tour request directly on this page or call our office.

Listing Agent

Cheryl Szczarba · (203) 996-8328

Seabury Hill REALTORS · (203) 562-1220

MLS# 24163983 · Data provided by SmartMLS. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Listing updated Apr 18, 2026 11:52 AM UTC