Central CT Inventory Up 23%. So Why Are Prices Still Rising?

A 23% Jump Off the Floor Isn't What You Think

23% more homes hit the Central CT market since the start of 2026. That number showed up in headlines this month, and I've had buyers call me sounding genuinely relieved - finally, they said, some breathing room. I understand why. The number looks promising. But the first question you need to ask is: 23% up from what?

Before this bump, inventory in towns like Southington, Berlin, and Newington was running 40-60% below historic norms. Not below last year's levels - below what was normal before the pandemic changed everything. We were at a generational low. Bidding wars were standard on anything remotely priced right. Homes were going in 72 hours. That's for sure.

So when you add 23% to a number already sitting at the floor, you're still looking at a market with fewer available homes than 2018 or 2019 - years when CT buyers were already competing hard. The 23% increase doesn't change the fundamental supply-demand math. Not even close.

Think about it this way. In a balanced market, buyers would typically have 3-5 months of inventory to choose from. Central CT has been running under one month for most of the past three years. A 23% increase on one month's worth of inventory is still one month's worth of inventory.

What I tell every buyer I work with: the right house in a good Central CT corridor still gets multiple offers in the first week. I watched it happen over and over this spring. Context matters a lot, lot more than the headline figure.

Who's Actually Selling Right Now

The people listing homes in Central CT right now are not the 2020-2021 buyers who locked in at 2-3% mortgage rates. Those owners are sitting tight. Moving would mean trading their rate for something near 7%, and the payment math simply doesn't work - even buying the same-sized house would cost hundreds more per month.

What's hitting the market is circumstantial inventory:

• Estate sales and probate listings
• Divorces and life transitions
• Job relocations - people who genuinely don't have a choice
• Pre-2018 buyers with enough equity that the rate trade-off doesn't kill the deal

These are not discretionary sellers who decided this spring felt like a good time. They're people who need to sell regardless of what the market is doing. That changes everything about the supply picture. You're not seeing a wave of family homes from move-up sellers who looked at a strong spring market and decided to jump in. Each listing is its own isolated situation driven by life circumstances - not market confidence.

Long story short - the 23% jump is real, but it's coming from the margins. The core of the ownership pool is not moving.

Demand Is Still Outrunning Supply

On the demand side, nothing has softened. Rents in most of Central CT are above $2,000 a month for a basic apartment. That's pushing first-time buyers into the market even at elevated rates, because the math of renting doesn't add up anymore. Pay $2,000 to rent, or put that toward a mortgage and start building equity - for most people, once they actually run that comparison, the answer is clear.

I've seen this play out dozens of times. A renter hits a lease renewal, sees the new number, and calls within a week. They weren't planning to buy. The rent math pushed them there. Every month of elevated rents is another wave of buyers entering the pipeline.

Basically, you've got a slightly larger pool of available homes being absorbed by an equally intense wave of buyers. The ratio is still wrong for buyers.

And move-up buyers who do decide to list? They have to buy somewhere after they sell. So they add to demand at the same time they add to supply. What looks like new supply is often just churn. Net effect on price pressure: close to zero.

The buyer pool isn't just first-timers either. Investors are active. Relocators from New York and New Jersey are still coming up looking for value relative to their home markets. And remote workers who came to CT during COVID and settled in? They're not leaving. The demand side of this equation has multiple layers, and inventory increases have to outpace all of them to matter.

What I tell first-time buyers right now: don't get lulled into thinking inventory is your friend yet. You have a bit more time to think than in 2022. But the homes worth buying are still moving fast.

The Market Is Splitting in Two

Six months ago, almost everything was moving - even homes priced a bit aggressively, even homes that needed obvious work. Buyers didn't have the leverage to be patient. Now they have slightly more options, and it shows.

The best homes - right price, right condition, right location - still go in a week with multiple offers. A Southington colonial that's well-maintained and priced to the comps? Gone. A Glastonbury place that checks all the boxes? Same story. That segment of the market looks exactly like 2022.

Anything that doesn't check the boxes is sitting. Overpriced listings are getting price cuts after two or three weeks on market. Homes that need substantial work are staying active longer because buyers now have enough alternatives that they don't have to settle. That red flag - a listing that's been on market too long - is back. Sellers who wanted to test the market and adjust are finding out it costs more than they thought.

There's a pattern I've noticed this spring. A home comes on market Friday. By Monday there are three showings scheduled. If by Wednesday there's no offer, the listing agent knows something is off - usually price, sometimes condition. The first week tells you everything. Homes that don't get offers in week one almost always have a pricing problem, and fixing it after the fact costs sellers more than getting it right on day one would have.

I'd call this healthy, actually. A market where great homes move fast and the rest have to earn their price is more functional than one where everything sells in a weekend regardless of condition. But don't mistake "problematic homes are sitting" for "it's a buyer's market."

What I'd Actually Do

If you're buying: this is not the time to wait. A few more options than last year is real, and you should use that to be more selective - find the right house instead of settling for something that mostly works. But when the right one shows up, move on it. Have your pre-approval done before you start looking. The homes that matter are still competitive, and being unprepared is how you lose them.

For sellers: overpricing now has consequences it didn't have six months ago. I've watched sellers list 5% above where the comps supported, sit for three weeks, and then chase the market down with cuts that ended up below where they should have started. Worst outcome possible - you signal weakness, lose the initial momentum, and net less than you would have with the right price from day one.

Prepare the house properly, understand what to do before listing, price it where the market actually is, and this market will reward you. I mean, I had sellers go under contract in five days this spring - priced correctly and the house was ready. The ones who weren't? Still waiting.

Frequently Asked Questions