Home Homes for Sale Old Lyme, CT 34-1 Johnny Cake Hill Road

34-1 Johnny Cake Hill Road, Old Lyme, CT 06371

Single Family For Sale

$1,199,900
$349/sqft
34-1 Johnny Cake Hill Road, Old Lyme, CT Active
Photo 2
Photo 3
Photo 4
Photo 5
3
Bedrooms
5
Bathrooms
3,435
Sq Ft
2.03
Acres
1978
Year Built

About This Home

A Bold House, Built for a Bold Life. Intentionally delivering scale, separation, and presence. Comprehensively reimagined in 2021, modern systems, elevated finishes, and a layout designed for lifestyle. The heart of the home is an expansive kitchen and dining space designed to perform. Quartz countertops, custom 42-inch cabinetry with dovetail construction, a dedicated chef's pantry, and Profile GE Series appliances, create a space that is perfect for large gatherings. Large Marvin windows pull natural light throughout the main living areas, highlighting substantial interior doors, and bold millwork. The Primary Suite is positioned intentionally separated for privacy and presence. Gas Fireplace, Walk-in Closet, an Elegant Dressing Room, Spa-Level Bath with Frameless Glass Double Shower, Dual Quartz Vanities, and a Private Water Closet. Secondary bedrooms are generously sized, each with its own full bath, offering autonomy for guests, family, or extended stays. Large additional living spaces provide flexibility- media, recreation, or home office. Hardie-plank siding, all New Roof in 2021, central air with 3 condensers, a newly installed underground propane tank, and leased solar panels support year-round comfort, efficiency, and ease of ownership. Old Lyme offers coastal New England character and cultural depth- beaches, an established arts community, proximity to the Old Lyme Country Club, and convenient access to major transportation routes to New York City and Boston.

Listed by John Roberto (860) 514-0500 with CENTURY 21 Shutters & Sails (860) 331-1510

Listing Snapshot

Price $1,199,900 Days on Market 14 days
Property Tax $14,078/yr Style Cape Cod,Contemporary
Year Built 1978 Total Sq Ft 3,435
Lot Size 2.03 acres HOA Fees N/A
Bedrooms 3 Full Bathrooms 4
Total Rooms 7 Half Baths 1

Key Features

Appliances
  • Gas Cooktop
  • Wall Oven
  • Microwave
  • Range Hood
  • Refrigerator
  • Dishwasher
  • Washer
  • Dryer
Outdoor
  • Porch
  • Lighting
  • Patio
Nearby
  • Golf Course
  • Health Club
  • Library
  • Paddle Tennis
  • Park
  • Private School(s)
  • Shopping/Mall

Structure & Parking

Construction Frame
Roof Asphalt Shingle,Metal
Garage Spaces 2
Garage Type Attached Garage

Systems & Utilities

Heat Hot Air
Fuel Propane
Cooling Central Air
Hot Water Propane, Tankless Hotwater
Water Private Well
Sewer Septic

Schools

Elem Per Board of Ed
High Lyme-Old Lyme

Mortgage Calculator

$
$
%
%
Est. Monthly Payment
Principal & Interest
Est. Property Tax $1,173/mo
Est. Home Insurance

Estimate only. Contact a lender for accurate figures.

Listing History

Date Event Price
Mar 9, 2026 Listed $1,199,900

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does 34-1 Johnny Cake Hill Road in Old Lyme, CT cost?
This property is listed at $1,199,900, which works out to $349 per square foot.
How many bedrooms does 34-1 Johnny Cake Hill Road have?
This home has 3 bedrooms and 5 bathrooms.
What is the square footage of 34-1 Johnny Cake Hill Road?
The home is 3,435 square feet, situated on 2.03 acres.
When was 34-1 Johnny Cake Hill Road in Old Lyme built?
This property was built in 1978.
Is 34-1 Johnny Cake Hill Road, Old Lyme, CT still available?
The current MLS status of this property is "Active". Contact RYZE Realty Group for the latest availability.
What school district is 34-1 Johnny Cake Hill Road, Old Lyme in?
This home is served by the Old Lyme public school system, with Per Board of Ed as the elementary school and Lyme-Old Lyme as the high school.
How do I schedule a tour of 34-1 Johnny Cake Hill Road, Old Lyme, CT?
Contact RYZE Realty Group to schedule a private showing. You can submit a tour request directly on this page or call our office.

Listing Agent

John Roberto · (860) 514-0500

CENTURY 21 Shutters & Sails · (860) 331-1510

MLS# 24158291 · Data provided by SmartMLS. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Listing updated Mar 27, 2026 1:20 PM UTC