The number everyone's texting me about
I got three messages this week from clients asking some version of the same thing: is the market crashing? Someone saw a headline that pending home sales just hit the lowest level since the index started being tracked in 2001. Down 7.3% in a single month. Down 11.3% from a year ago. That's not a small dip. That's the worst reading NAR has ever recorded for this number.
I get why that's scary to read if you're sitting on a house you want to sell, or you're a buyer wondering if you should wait this out. But here's the thing nobody puts in the headline: that national number is an average of fifty different markets moving in completely different directions. And Connecticut, specifically Hartford, is not behaving anything like the national story.
Let me put it this way - if the national market is a patient running a fever, Hartford barely has a temperature.
What "pending sales" actually measures (and why it matters more than you think)
Most people hear housing market news and think of the existing-home-sales report - homes that already closed. That number tells you what happened a month or two ago, because closings happen after a long chain of inspections, appraisals, and mortgage underwriting.
The Pending Home Sales Index is different. Basically, it counts signed contracts - homes where a buyer and seller agreed on terms and went under contract, but haven't closed yet. That makes it a leading indicator. It's telling you what's about to happen, not what already happened.
So when this index craters nationally, it means buyers are pulling back from signing contracts right now, in real time. That's a more honest read on current demand than a closed-sales number that's reporting on deals signed back in July or August.
Why the Northeast - and Hartford specifically - didn't follow the national script
Here's where it gets interesting. NAR breaks the country into four regions, and the Northeast posted the smallest monthly decline of any of them - down 4.2% month-over-month and 9.4% year-over-year. Still a decline, I'm not going to pretend otherwise. But roughly half the national drop.
Then zoom into the metro-level data and it gets even more specific. Among the fifty largest metros in the country, Hartford-West Hartford-East Hartford posted one of the smallest annual declines of any of them, at -2.1%. The only metro that did better was Nashville, at -2.0%. Out of fifty major metros in the entire country, Hartford was basically tied for first in holding steady.
That's not a coincidence. We've talked before about why inventory here is so tight - people locked into 2-3% mortgages from 2020 and 2021 aren't moving, because moving means trading that rate for something much higher. That structural lock-in that's been frustrating buyers in Southington, Berlin, and Newington for two years is the same dynamic that's keeping contract activity from falling off a cliff here. Less supply, sure, but the demand side hasn't disappeared either. Rents in CT have pushed past $2,000 a month for a basic apartment in plenty of towns, and that's pushing first-time buyers into contracts even at today's rates.
Why the South and West are falling harder
So I'm not going to pretend to have inside data on every metro in the country, but the pattern is consistent with what's been building for a while. Markets that saw the biggest price run-ups during COVID, a lot of them in the Sun Belt, also built a lot more new construction to meet that demand. More supply plus buyers who are more rate-sensitive equals bigger pullbacks when rates stay elevated.
Connecticut never had that construction boom. We didn't overbuild in 2021 and 2022, so we don't have a surplus to work through now. Basically, the states where new pending contracts are falling hardest are the ones that had the most room to fall. Hartford doesn't have that room because the supply problem here was never solved in the first place.
That's a very different situation than a market correcting after overbuilding. One is a slowdown. The other is a market that was already starved for inventory and just kept going.
What this means if you're selling in Southington, Glastonbury, or anywhere in between
The biggest risk right now isn't the market - it's a seller reading a scary national headline and panic-pricing their home below what it's actually worth here. That's just not the smartest move. If you price based on what you read about Phoenix or Austin, you're leaving money on the table in a market where contract activity barely moved.
Price is still the only reason a home sits, full stop. That was true before this report came out and it's true after. A well-priced home in Southington, Berlin, or Farmington is still going to get attention, because the fundamentals that have been driving our market haven't changed because of one national data point. These fundamentals are the inventory squeeze, the rate lock-in, and the first-time buyer pressure. Overpricing by even 5% in this environment means sitting while correctly priced inventory moves. Price is the only lever.
- Don't drop your asking price because of a national headline that doesn't reflect your local comps
- Do expect slightly less urgency than peak 2021-2022, but not a collapse
- Do prepare the home properly - curb appeal, decluttering, a deep clean - because buyers still have standards even when they have less competition to worry about
What this means if you're buying
But if you're a buyer and you read that headline and thought "great, finally some breathing room" - slow down before you assume competition has vanished. Hartford's -2.1% tells you contracts are still getting signed here at nearly the same pace as last year. Bidding wars are still common in towns like Southington, Berlin, West Hartford, Glastonbury, Simsbury, and Farmington on the right houses - fully renovated, good kitchens, good location. Those disappear fast.
The data gives you a more accurate read on your actual odds than a scary national headline does. You're not walking into a market in free fall. You're walking into a market that's tight, competitive in the right price bands, and moving at close to the same pace it was a year ago. Come in with full pre-approval, not just pre-qualification, because sellers here are still expecting that level of seriousness. The stuff that mattered six months ago still matters now.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does the Pending Home Sales Index actually measure?
It tracks signed contracts on existing homes, not closed sales. Because contracts typically close one to two months later, it's considered a leading indicator - it tells you where the market is heading before the closed-sales numbers catch up.
Why did Hartford do so much better than the national average?
Hartford never saw the overbuilding that hit Sun Belt markets during the pandemic, so there's no excess supply to work through now. Combined with homeowners locked into low mortgage rates and strong first-time buyer demand, contract activity here stayed close to flat while much of the country saw sharp declines.
Does a record-low national pending sales number mean home prices will drop in Connecticut?
Not based on what the local data shows. Hartford's pending sales fell just 2.1% year-over-year, one of the smallest declines among the 50 largest U.S. metros, which suggests demand here is holding up even as it weakens nationally.
Should I wait to sell my house until the market 'calms down'?
No. Waiting based on a national headline that doesn't reflect your local market usually just costs you time and, often, money. If your home is priced correctly for Southington, Berlin, or wherever you are in Central CT, it will still attract buyers.
Is now a bad time to buy in Hartford County because rates are high?
Rates are a separate issue from whether the local market has slowed down, and it hasn't slowed down much here. If you find a house you want and can afford the payment, lock it in. You can always refinance later if rates drop, but waiting indefinitely has historically left buyers watching prices rise instead.
