RYZE Realty Group · 860.406.4060

CT Just Approved Home Insurance Rate Cuts. Most Owners Still Pay More

October 29, 2026 · 6 min read
A photorealistic shot of a Connecticut homeowner checking their mailbox and pulling out a renewal notice envelope from a
Share this article:

The announcement that got everyone's attention

On October 16, the Connecticut Insurance Department put out something people haven't seen in years: a list of rate decreases. Not increases. Decreases.

The department flagged 19 personal auto filings from 14 companies and 19 homeowners filings from 16 companies that included rate cuts for certain consumers. Liberty Mutual and its affiliated companies cut homeowners rates by about 5% for more than 30,000 policies in Connecticut. Farmers Casualty filed an average auto rate decrease around 14%. State Farm's affiliated companies came in around 8.4% on auto.

30,000+ Liberty Mutual homeowners policies getting a rate cut in CT

I had clients texting me about this within a day of it hitting the news. People have been getting hammered on premiums for years, and the second a headline says "rate decrease," everyone wants to know if it's their turn.

Slow down before you get excited. This is real, and it's good news. But it's not the blanket relief some of the headlines made it sound like.

Here's the part most people are skipping over

Commissioner Josh Hershman said it plainly - rate changes vary by insurer, coverage, and rating factors, so not everyone sees a lower premium. He called the filings "a positive development," not a fix.

Basically, these decreases apply to certain consumers, not every single policyholder with that carrier. A Liberty Mutual homeowners cut doesn't mean every Liberty Mutual customer in Connecticut got 5% knocked off. It means a specific pool of policies, based on rating factors like location, construction type, claims history, coverage limits, and so on, qualifies for the new filed rate.

Worth knowing: CID's release did not publish effective dates for these new rates. When they kick in depends on your individual renewal cycle, not a single statewide date.

So if your renewal notice shows up next month and the number is the same as last year, that doesn't mean the announcement was fake. It just means your policy wasn't one of the ones affected, or your renewal hasn't hit the new filed rate yet. Check before you assume anything.

Why this happened now

This isn't the first time the state has pushed back on insurers. In CID's 2025 property-casualty rate review, insurers requested an average homeowners increase of 9.1%. The department approved 8.7% instead, which saved policyholders a reported $10.34 million that year.

But rates still went up in 2025. The department just trimmed how much they went up. That's a very different thing than what's being announced now, where certain filings are actual decreases, not smaller increases.

So you've got two trends running at the same time. CID has been quietly shaving down requested increases for a couple years. And now, for the first time in a while, a batch of carriers filed actual decreases for some policyholders. That's meaningfully different, and it's worth paying attention to, but it doesn't erase what happened the last few years.

I've had clients in Southington and Berlin tell me their premiums climbed noticeably even while their homes didn't change at all - no new roof, no claims, nothing. That's been the frustrating part. Rates kept climbing regardless of behavior. This announcement is the first real signal that the direction might be shifting for some people.

What to actually do about it

I tell my clients the same thing every time a story like this comes out: don't wait around assuming it applies to you automatically. Call your agent.

  • Ask your current carrier directly if your policy is part of a filed rate decrease, and when it takes effect on your renewal
  • Get a comparison quote from at least one other carrier at renewal, even if you've been loyal to the same company for years
  • Ask specifically about the homeowners filings versus auto filings - they're separate, and the percentages are different for each
  • Don't assume Liberty Mutual, Farmers, or State Farm customers automatically get a lower bill just because those names were in the headlines

That's the most important move here. Insurance companies are not going to call you up and say "hey, you qualify for less." You have to ask. The decrease exists on paper at the state level. Whether it reaches your specific bill is a different question, and the only way to find out is to check. You have to ask.

Worth knowing: If you're shopping homes right now in a town with a higher effective tax burden, like Waterbury or West Hartford, insurance costs matter even more in your monthly budget math. A small rate cut on one line item doesn't offset a high tax bill on another.

What this means if you're buying or selling right now

For buyers, this matters because insurance cost is part of what actually makes a monthly payment comfortable or not. The lender approving you for a certain amount doesn't mean you should spend right up to that number. Insurance, taxes, maintenance - they all stack on top of the mortgage payment. A flat or slightly lower insurance rate helps the math. But it's one piece, not the whole picture.

Sellers, this isn't going to move your sale price. Buyers aren't pricing homes based on insurance rate filings. But if you're fielding questions from a nervous buyer worried about ongoing costs in a town like Hamden or East Hartford where tax burdens run higher, having a realistic conversation about total carrying costs - insurance included - builds trust. It shows you're not just trying to close the deal and disappear.

This is also a good reminder for anyone who hasn't shopped their insurance in a few years. Loyalty doesn't get you a better rate automatically. Carriers file new rates constantly, and the only way you benefit is if you ask. Ask anyway.

Bottom line: Real decreases exist for some CT policyholders right now. But "some" is the key word. Call your agent, ask directly if you qualify, and don't wait for a mailer to tell you.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does this mean my Connecticut home insurance bill will go down automatically?

No. The rate decreases apply to certain consumers based on the insurer's specific filing, not every policyholder with that company. You need to contact your agent or carrier directly to find out if your policy qualifies.

When do these new lower insurance rates take effect in CT?

The Connecticut Insurance Department's release did not publish specific effective dates. Timing depends on your individual policy's renewal cycle, so check with your carrier about your own renewal date.

Which insurance companies filed rate decreases in Connecticut?

CID identified 19 personal auto filings from 14 companies and 19 homeowners filings from 16 companies with decreases. Liberty Mutual cut homeowners rates about 5% for over 30,000 CT policies, Farmers Casualty filed roughly a 14% auto decrease, and State Farm affiliates filed around 8.4% off auto rates.

Why did Connecticut home insurance rates go up so much the last few years?

Rising rebuilding costs, more frequent severe weather claims, and reinsurance costs pushed insurers to request large increases statewide. CID's 2025 review still approved an average 8.7% homeowners increase even after trimming insurer requests down from 9.1%.

Should I shop around for new home insurance now that rates are dropping for some people?

Yes. Even if your current carrier isn't one of the ones offering a decrease, comparing quotes at renewal is the only reliable way to know if you're overpaying relative to the current market.

Peter Nowak

Written By

Peter Nowak

Peter Nowak is the broker and one of the owners of RYZE Realty Group, a real estate brokerage based in Southington, CT.

Peter writes all content on this blog and personally reviews and approves every post before it goes live. Posts are occasionally refined with AI assistance for clarity and flow. The expertise, opinions, and local knowledge are always his own.